The 15 Best Places for NY Style Pizza in Brooklyn (2024)

Sylvester:Authentic NYC style pizza slice 🍕

Scott Reilly:One of the best traditional New York style pizzas

Joe Kanakaraj:This is one of the better counter slice spots in Brooklyn. Traditional NYC slice. No fancy, over the top toppings. Just a perfect slice of pizza.

kwik.buck:This is really good NY style pizza. Lots of variety here.

Alex:Best slice NYC style pizza

Dan:Excellent pizza, best slice in Williamsburg (including Joe’s and Best Pizza)

Buford Barnes:Some of the best coal oven New York style pizza ever made.

Sylvia Howard:Super friendly wait staff. True New York Style Pizza...delicious!

Kartik Sathappan:The hype is real. Best NY style pizza on earth.

Kenny Hom:The original Patsy Grimaldi is back running his old haunt, 20 years after selling his old pizzeria! If they stick to his exacting standards, this will be the best NY pizza you can get.

Gretchen Gantner:Gourmet New York style pizza.

Keith Lea:Pretty fun pizza choices. I feel like it's halfway between the fancy thin crust wood fired style & the greasy NY pizza slice style

Peter Martin:Try the New York style pizza

Roger R:Top 5 pizza anywhere. This place defines NY pizza and is a must try along with the other greats.

John Τσεντζελης:If you want some old school style brick oven pizza with some great flavor, you need to stop here. This place is definitely a gem that everyone should come to and enjoy some great pizza.

Stacy H:Some of the best NY pizza period. Not to be outshined, their calzones (I recommend garlic+hot pepper+ basil) are rich, creamy goodness and are TO DIE FOR. Make sure you save room.

Buford Barnes:Some of the best wood oven New York style pizza in the city, if not the world. Jay-Z apparently gets his pizza here.

Eater:Lucali still serves some of the city's finest pizzas, and the dining room is a real beauty. [Eater 38 Member]

Cristina Couloucoundis:The pepperoni with hot honey is damn good and you’d never know it just by looking at the place. Highly recommended for great NY pizza - and the chef really has his heart in it.

Funes:When people talk about NY pizza, this is what talk about. Expensive but worth every penny, you can take your own wine.

Emily Wilson:This is the best NY pizza there is. Prepare to wait longer than you're quoted but it is 100% worth it. Highly recommend a square slice with soppressata, even if you're already getting a regular pie.

Bob T:Classic NY Pizza from one of the greatest pizzaiolas in the world.

New York Habitat:Great authentic New York style pizza and one of the best in the city. Don't bother with whole pies, just get a slice or two to go and enjoy it at the nearby Cadman Plaza Park. Cash only.

Hari Nino Jimenez:Great authentic New York style pizza and one of the best in the city

Sandro Pugliese:like good europeans, they close for most of august

Simone Hara:Try the NY Style Pizza

Jesse Bagels:A Brooklyn staple, when you rate NY pizza you bypass this and DiFara's and then start, this is a whole different echelon of slice

Paul Mcnamee:We had a great time. The wait was long but we started with a half pizza outside then moved over to dinner. Baked clams and chicken pram were awesome. Don't miss the Spumoni

Meela Palomx:A Famous Celebrity NY pizza 🍕 spot #AskMeeLA

Gilbert Wong:Had a slice with both pepperoni & sausage. It was one of the best tasting I’ve ever had anywhere!

Joseph Pedicino:Eggplant ,spinach rolls and specialty pizza

Julie JEWELeS:Try the The Vesuvio - First NY pizza! (via @Foodspotting)

Visit LYSPER.com:We come here often and both the food and the service are always amazing! The classic cuisine is consistently delicious and we recommend it to everyone. One of our favorite restaurants in Brooklyn... Read more.

Bill D:Best chicken parm in Brooklyn. Hands down.

Boberto Patricio:Keep walking. Its amazing what passes for 'NY' pizza. All 2.50 slices are not created equal. Just jump on the 62 and head to la Nonna in Willy B

Arlean Gillin:When in area, Not Ray's is a must. Quick slice and on my way either on bus or train which are literally right in front. Quality, cheese, sauce and crust..yummy

💪Jig💪:Best Pizza in BK.

Randy Reynolds:Good New York style pizza!

Jeffrey Vargas:Best slices and sicilians anywhere in the area. Been a staple for my family for 40+ years

Robert Mulley:BBQ chicken slice is amazing

Patti P. Rice:Perfect NY pizza no yuppie bullsh*t

Observer4169:Best general "neighborhood pie" around. Can't go wrong.

Jason Leibowitz:One of the best pizza places in New York, not even Brooklyn!